The Same Shade
by Cass
· 12/03/2026
Published 12/03/2026 17:57
Walgreens, cosmetics aisle, 1997 walking toward me.
The exact lipstick I took when I was sixteen,
that small theft that tasted like electricity,
like I was finally someone worth arresting.
I didn't steal it this time.
But my heart did that same old crime—
hammering, my palms went slick,
and I felt the old trick
of my own teenage hands reaching.
The cashier's face from back then
watches me still. I see her when
I close my eyes, know what she knew—
that I was guilty, that guilt grew
quieter but never quite left.
I walked out without it.
But something in me couldn't quit
the feeling of having taken something
that wasn't mine, becoming
someone I still can't forgive.